TV! Search
American Idol

American Idol Rankings

Results: Which former contestant is the better performer?

Idol Rank Vote %
Carrie Underwood 1 71%
Clay Aiken 2 70%
Chris Daughtry 3 69%
Kelly Clarkson 4 68%
Jordin Sparks 5 67%
Melinda Doolittle 6 65%
Jennifer Hudson 7 60%
Blake Lewis 8 59%
Katharine McPhee 9 58%
Bo Bice 10 58%
Kellie Pickler 11 56%
Elliott Yamin 12 55%
Kimberley Locke 13 52%
Fantasia Barrino 14 51%
Taylor Hicks 15 50%
Constantine Maroulis 16 50%
Ruben Studdard 17 50%
Lakisha Jones 18 48%
Diana DeGarmo 19 48%
Paris Bennett 20 47%
Lisa Tucker 21 43%
Justin Guarini 22 40%
Jasmine Trias 23 39%
George Huff 24 37%
Trenyce 25 36%
John Stevens 26 28%
Scott Savol 27 27%
Sanjaya Malakar 28 27%
William Hung 29 22%
Launch The Ranker

Additional Rankings

Who has the superior vocal skills?

Idol Rank Votes
David Archuleta 1 83%
David Cook 2 76%
Carly Smithson 3 75%
Michael Johns 4 74%
Brooke White 5 68%

Who has more star potential?

Idol Rank Votes
David Archuleta 1 79%
Michael Johns 2 75%
Carly Smithson 3 72%
David Cook 4 72%
Brooke White 5 71%

Who takes more heat from Simon?

Idol Rank Votes
Danny Noriega 1 69%
Kristy Lee Cook 2 65%
Kady Malloy 3 61%
Garrett Haley 4 60%
Jason Yeager 5 57%