TV! Search

American Idol TV Show - American Idol Television Show - Yahoo! TV

American Idol

American Idol User Reviews

Average User Rating
4 stars
Based on 98302 ratings
Sign in to Rate
Sort By
Showing 1 of 12861
  • 5 stars

    Anxiously waiting the new season...

    October 14, 2009
    All the hype about who's is going to judge American Idol this year is just a waste of breath. Everyone knows that SIMON is the backbone of the show and also the backbone of all the judges so, I'm sure that anyone who sits beside him to help judge American Idol will do just fine. The show is not about finding the best judge, it's all about finding the next american idol. As far as Ellen filling Paulas seat, she will do just fine. The woman is smart, funny, very talented and has a heart of gold. She also has music in her soul, look at the girl dance, she feels the rythum. I think a different kind of insight for the new talent this coming season will be a good change. So, please don't JUDGE Ellen until you see her in action. I'm sure she will be a pleasant addition to the show and the shows ratings will sky rocket with her help. As far as Paula....yes, she will be missed but not enough to ruin Idol and I'm sure that won't be the last we hear of Paula. She's been around many years and who knows what she has up her sleeve to stay in the public eye. Good luck Paula. Cheers to Ellen for being selected to be an Idol judge. Those producers know what they are doing and that's why out of everyone they could have chosen, they chose Ellen. Variety, charm, laughter and Simon is the key to keeping everyones attention. Just look, the show hasn't even started yet and talk of it is buzzing all over the media and TV industry, that's an excellant start for the new season....GO IDOL!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
    Was this review helpful to you? Sign in to rate
  • 5 stars

    Ellen vs. Paula

    October 2, 2009
    We will miss Paula but I think that Ellen will do a great job. Ellen can really give Simon a run for his money. She is one great entertainer and is so very kind and loving to everyone. Give her a chance people and Ellen will prove to be wonderfully funny and delightfully inspiring to many contestants and the panel.
    Paula will do alright. She always does. She'll come through somewhere else with her beauty and charm. She always does.
    I can't wait to see the next episode of "Idol" and the delightful humor and talent that is there. I love the show. Keep up the good work. .
    Was this review helpful to you? Sign in to rate
  • 5 stars

    Idol and Ellen

    September 26, 2009
    The choice of Ellen as a judge is obviously because she can persuade her fans to support the media favorite.

    Whether it would have been real or manufactured support, the talk show hosts that were gaga over Adam Lambert, wished they could have said that the American Idol viewers wanted Adam on their love seats too. Even though talks show hosts are out of touch, they like to pretend.
    Was this review helpful to you? Sign in to rate
  • 4 stars

    not watching

    September 22, 2009
    paula is the reason we watch this show she is the greatest especially with simon now that ellen is on were not going to watch it any more i cant stand her paula is a big key to the show u made a big mistake
    Was this review helpful to you? Sign in to rate
  • 3 stars

    Missing Paula

    September 15, 2009
    I love Ellen, but the show won't be the same without Paula. Please bring her back! She's a big part of the show. First you brought in the other woman, (can't think of her name) who is nice, but not nearly as interesting as Paula. I just don't know if I'll watch the show or not. It will never be the same.
    Was this review helpful to you? Sign in to rate
Showing 1 of 12861

TV Listings

Eastern Time Zone Stand ...

TV Listings Setup »
Got Tivo? Record Now