I really don't understand why people think that if one Sherlock Holmes is good, another cannot exist therefore is doomed. I felt that the story was very entertaining, the characters had great chemistry. Takes the place of The Closer for me. The writer's were actually clever to put the story in New York , and have Sherlock Holmes be in rehab. Some people have imagination. I love the other Sherlock Holmes also but this is a totally different story. Thank you CBS for putting this in the line up.