TV! Search

Top Chef TV Show - Top Chef Television Show - Yahoo! TV

Top Chef

Top Chef User Reviews

Wednesday at 01:00 pm BRAVO (ch 51)
Average User Rating
4.5 stars
Based on 5259 ratings
Sign in to Rate
Sort By
Showing 1 of 547
  • 3 stars

    Sometimes I question

    January 10, 2007
    Don't get me wrong. I love this show.However, I believe that the judges have their priorities in the wrong place from time to time. I just finished watching the last episode in which Michael was told to pack his knives. Marcel should have been sent home. He served a dish that was a HEALTH RISK! And in real life it wouldn't have mattered if every thing else on his menu was absolutely delightful, serving undercooked chicken would have ruined deterred people from returning. The judges chief complaint about Michael tonight was that he didn't buy bowls for the olive pits. How can that even begin to be worse than serving a dish that contains something that can cause someone to be deathly ill? Sure Marcel's tempura may have been great but in my opinion that doesn't make up for putting people at risk. If I were a judge, Marcel would have gone home. I don't think many would argue with that. Except the judges of course. The more I watch the more I see the inconsistencies on the way the judges judge. They send people home based on the looks of the dish, the consistency. Well, they should realize that the people who are going to be eating this food prefer for the food to taste good. You have a food that tastes awesome, who cares what it looks like. Heaven help them if a Cajun ever gets on the show. Cajun food doesn't always look appealing but it has incredible flavor and always tastes good.
    Was this review helpful to you? Sign in to rate
  • 2 stars

    Won't watch again

    January 30, 2007
    I have found this series to be the worst! I have loved and watched every other one, but will not watch the final. Marcel is OBVIOUSLY someones favorite and it comes across loud and clear. Sam won more, did more and was far more consistent throughout.....Elan and Sam should be in the running. Sorry but it was too obvious that this show is not what it is supposed to be. I will not watch again.

    Thanks for some great shows in the earlier series but you really missed the mark on this one.....Judges have a serious problem with consistency.

    LLM
    Was this review helpful to you? Sign in to rate
  • 5 stars

    Go Marcel!

    January 28, 2007
    The show is fun, though I think this group of cooks behaves like petulant children. I love all the BS about Marcel. I LOVE him. That boob Cliff is gone, for being a jerk, and for simply crossing the line. And as the judges said: he'd be gone anyway because his food sucked.

    But what I love is what Judge/Chef Tom said when Elia whined (before she was axed) about Marcel. He said: We don't care what you do in the kitchen. It's all about the food"....., and this is what Marcel keeps saying. He doesn't care about making friends. He's there for the competition.

    Hey, he's obviously better than Betty......goody-two-shoes whiner; Sam, hated Marcel......and now GONE. Bye bye!

    GO MARCEL!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
    Was this review helpful to you? Sign in to rate
  • 4 stars

    How disappointing

    January 25, 2007
    Marcel must have paid off the judges and producers to be voted for the final 2. Sam by far is the top chef over Marcel. Sam won so many contests or was at the top and they even asked for seconds on Wed. night show from Sam. I thought Top Chef would be the one who was consistant throughout. I guess I don't have to bother watching next week.
    Was this review helpful to you? Sign in to rate
  • 3 stars

    This program is off my list...

    January 25, 2007
    These judges are NUTS. During the last episode, they made a point of saying that top chefs have to be leaders, work with a team, etc. (when they were chastising the group after Cliff strong-armed Marcel and got himself kicked off). That being the case, why would they stand behind Marcel--he has NEVER been able to get along with anyone. He is pompous, selfish, self-serving--obnoxious. He should have been eliminated weeks ago! And, as for Tom's comment last night that Sam didn't cook anything, Merriam's definition of "cook" states "to prepare food for eating," so Tom is WRONG. I will not watch the final episode because the wrong people were selected. The judges should be eliminated!
    Was this review helpful to you? Sign in to rate
Showing 1 of 547

TV Listings

Eastern Time Zone Stand ...

TV Listings Setup »
Got Tivo? Record Now